Norman Didn't Do It! (Yes, he did.)

Norman Didn't Do It!: by Ryan T. Higgins
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Norman and Mildred are best friends. The fact that one is a porcupine and the other a tree makes no difference at all. That is, until the day that a seedling begins to grow nearby. Then Norman's worries sprout and take root as well, until he feels the new tree is such a threat to his relationship with Mildred that he digs it up in the dark of night and takes it far, far away. Fixed! Except...it didn't fix anything, and now Norman feels horribly guilty and ashamed of himself. What's a porcupine to do?

As always, Ryan T. Higgins' artwork is worth many thousands of words. So much nuance and emotion conveyed with his illustrations. Brilliant, as always.

I love that this is a book depicting someone making a horrible choice, realizing the harm his actions have caused, coming up with a plan to make amends, and following through--a really critical life skill! And this book does it in such a way that it doesn't come across as preachy or afterschool-special-y. A great read-aloud for preschool through early elementary school. Or let's be honest, it's a great read for *adults* too!

View all my reviews

 

Monsters and Mold

Monsters and Mold by Asia Citro
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Zoey and her pet cat Sassafras are back with their second magical creature to help. This time they meet Gorp, a monster who wants to attend the upcoming Monster Ball but cannot bear to go with his fur all moldy. Zoey and Sassafras have less than a week to figure out how to stop the mold from growing, and it's going to take some scientific experimentation to find a solution.

The second book in the series delighted my kids just as much as the first. I really appreciated how Zoey didn't give up when her first (and second) theories didn't solve the problem. She kept using the scientific method to figure out what went wrong and why, giving her a new direction to try the next time.

One thing that bugged me and kept this book from a 5-star rating was that Zoey focused on treating the effect (the mold) and not the cause. Figuring out why something is occurring in the first place and preventing *that* is so often a much more valuable use of time. I mean, she did think to have Gorp make sure he didn't go to bed with wet fur, so that was good, but when that didn't stop the mold growth, she didn't revisit to see what other factors might be in play. And yes, I realize this is a very adult, nitpicky thing to pay attention to in a book aimed at young elementary school children. But it's my review, and this is a science-based book!

I have no idea whether Gorp will make a return appearance in any future books in the series, but if he does, I hope we find out more about why Sassafras is so drawn to Gorp. I kept expecting it to somehow relate to the mold problem--like maybe because Gorp's fur was, I don't know, covered in catnip or something. But alas, no clue!

For readers' advisors: story doorway is primary. This is a great STEM title for kids ages 4 to 9 or so. Human characters are drawn as African American. Lots of illustrations to go with the story, and the main character is a strong female who loves science.

View all my reviews

 

Dragons and Marshmallows

Dragons and Marshmallows by Asia Citro
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

Zoey's mom is packing for a work trip when Zoey stumbles across an old photograph of her mom as a child. But it's no ordinary photo--this one glows, and Zoey is the first person other than her mom to be able to see the glowing purple frog in the photo. Next thing she knows, Zoey is in charge of monitoring the secret doorbell on the barn, which magical creatures ring when they need help. At first nothing happens, but eventually the bell chimes. Zoey and her cat, Sassafras, must figure out how to nurse a tiny dragon back to health. Thinking Goggles and the scientific method to the rescue!

My kids LOVE this book and series. Every night they beg to read "just one more chapter, Mommy! No, TWO more chapters!" They love the magical creatures and the problem-solving skills Zoey uses. I love how the STEM concepts are woven into the story! For example, Zoey follows the rules of scientific experimentation to change Just One Thing At A Time, observes how that change affects the result and adjusts accordingly if it doesn't have the desired effect. Zoey makes science a delightful adventure.

For readers' advisors: story doorway is primary, character secondary. Zoey's skin color and hair indicate she is most likely African American, though it's not mentioned in the text of the book. In our household it's a read-aloud; the text itself is about a third-grade reading level.

View all my reviews

 

Case of the Vanishing Visitor

Case of the Vanishing Visitor by Shanna Swendson
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

It's been a long, slow news week for Lexie Lincoln, editor of the Stirling Mills Gazette, and by the time she's sent the paper to press, she's ready for her weekly Tex-Mex dinner at Margarita's restaurant. This week, the place is hopping, with no time to socialize with the staff, but Lexie is joined at the bar by a visitor, Florence Marz, who is in town to house sit for a friend. The two women have a great chat and agree to meet the next day so Lexie can interview Florrie about her impressions of the town. The next morning, however, Florrie doesn't show up and doesn't answer her phone. Lexie's instincts tell her something is amiss, yet no one else remembers seeing the woman in the restaurant. Since Lexie can see and talk to ghosts, the first thing she must do is determine whether she had dinner with a living person or a dead one. Once she answers that question, next up is what happened to Florrie, and why. Lexie does voice her concerns to a certain handsome police officer, who knows to take her seriously, but once the evidence starts to add up, it is just a little too perfect, so Lexie decides to keep digging until things start to make sense.

The fourth installment in the Lucky Lexie series is a fast, plot-driven read. I thoroughly enjoyed it, though I do wish the slow-burn romance between Lexie and Wes wasn't quite so very slow. But at least this book builds on the secrets shared in the previous book, and they use those to work together to solve the mystery.

For readers' advisors: story doorway is primary. There is no sex or swearing, and no real violence, though Lexie is threatened with a gun. There is virtually no character development in this book, but it relies on relationships built in the first three books, so reading them in order is highly recommended.

View all my reviews

 

Payback's a Witch

Payback's a Witch by Lana Harper
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Emmy Harlow left town as soon as she graduated from high school and has only been back to visit a few times since then, determined to live a magic-free life on her own terms in Chicago, after a painful breakup from an ill-advised secret romance with the Blackmoore family scion decimated her self-esteem. Now 26, Emmy has a job she adores, a mountain of student-loan debt, and a fierce desire to maintain her distance from everyone and everything she used to love. Enter The Gauntlet, a centuries-old tradition wherein the scions of the town's magical founding families compete once "every fifty years to determine which founding family got to preside over all things magical in Thistle Grove." The Harlow scion is the impartial Arbiter, and Emmy is the Harlow scion.

Her first night back in town, Emmy heads to a local bar and encounters her worst nightmare: Gareth Blackmoore and his drunk buddies. For his part, Gareth...absolutely doesn't recognize her and tries to hit on her, stunned that his pickup lines fail to impress. Natalia Avramov witnesses Emmy and Gareth's encounter and, to Emmy's shock, not only recognizes but actively remembers her from high school, though Talia was two years ahead. The women spend the rest of the evening drinking and bonding. The following morning, Emmy drags her pounding head to brunch with her BFF Linden Thorn and gets another shock: not only has Talia also had..."unfortunate relations" with Gareth, but he recently broke Lin's heart. Talia crashes their brunch to propose revenge: an unprecedented alliance between the Thorn scion (Lin's twin brother Rowan) and Avramov scion (Talia) against the Blackmoore scion (Gareth) at the upcoming Gauntlet. Though the challenges cannot be known in advance, plotting and planning provides ample time for sparks to fly between Talia and Emmy. Will those sparks be enough to rekindle Emmy's love for their town, or will they flame out as the Gauntlet ends?

This book was great fun to read, especially the descriptions of how the magic felt as it roared through Emmy, and I really enjoyed the steamy romance between Talia and Emmy, though sometimes I wanted to remind them that relationships which last cannot be built from chemistry alone--feeling "at home" with your partner is far more important than flutters and zings. Reading Emmy's struggle with her quarter-life crisis made me grateful to be past that phase of life. So much angst and self-delusion, so much pointless resistance to that which feeds her soul. I also appreciated that for all the angst, sexuality was a non-issue. No one batted at eye at Emmy being bisexual or Talia having a strong preference for women, yet also having a foolish fling with a man after a bad breakup. Humans are humans, and heartbreak is heartbreak.

I look forward to book two in the series, which presumably will feature Rowan and Isidora. Perhaps the author will flesh out some unanswered world-building questions in that installment, such as how intermarriage between founding families affects magical abilities and bloodlines. Surely this has come up at some point in the past 300 years? They can't *all* have married "normies." Or along those same lines, how are family names passed down? Specifically, do men who marry into the founding families take their wives' last names? Is that how Emmy's grandmother was able to keep and pass on the Harlow name? Or Gareth's grandmother? These questions and others didn't keep me from enjoying the story, but they did make me stop and wonder.

For readers' advisors: story and character doorways are both strong. There is a lot of swearing and drinking (I am seriously concerned for their livers!) but no violence. Tons of flirting, raging hormones, sexy thoughts and banter--in short, it's pretty steamy/spicy, but not especially explicit. The Gauntlet is reminiscent of the Triwizarding Tournament in Harry Potter.

Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the eGalley ARC in exchange for my honest opinion!

View all my reviews

The Shaadi Set-Up

The Shaadi Set-Up by Lillie Vale
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Six years ago, Milan broke up with Rita via voicemail while she was enroute to meet up with him for a European vacation the summer after their sophomore year in college. He shattered her heart, and she hasn't gotten over it in the slightest, despite all her protestations to the contrary. Now Milan is a successful real estate agent...with one exception. He has a house on the market he hasn't been able to sell, and he needs Rita's design help to stage it. Their mothers conspire to set up a meet and manipulate them into working together in the hopes that the reunion will give them a second chance.

What the mothers don't know is that Rita already has a boyfriend, and she isn't interested in giving Milan a second chance. She convinces her boyfriend they should coordinate their profiles on the Desi dating site, MyShaadi.com, so they will match, thereby "proving" they are right for each other. Unsurprisingly, they don't match with each other at all, and soon Rita's boyfriend is dating other women, and Rita is spending all her time fixing up a second home with Milan. However, for a relationship to be successful, the past and present must be reconciled.

I have had a hard time deciding on a rating for this book. I really wanted to like it more than I did. There were some very enjoyable aspects to it but also some aspects that just didn't work for me. I vacillated between two and three stars, for an average of 2.5 stars, which I will round up since half stars aren't an option in Goodreads.

What I enjoyed most about the book was the glimpse into Indian-American culture, much of the banter, and the interactions between Rita and her best friend Rajvee. I also appreciated the steamy foreplay that led into the tasteful fade-to-black sex scenes. And I loved that it was Rita who was the expert with power tools and refurbishing furniture. The story kept me reading and went by pretty quickly.

Overall, though, the book made me grateful I'm not still in my twenties. Ugh. So much angst, so few deep conversations. I just don't understand how it took six whole years for Rita and Milan to uncover the misunderstanding that caused their breakup, given that both maintained contact with Raj. That's a pretty big Best Friend Fail to NEVER talk about such a pivotal event or connect the dots to realize there was more to the story.

I think the love triangle would have been more effective had Neil not been such an obvious mismatch. I wanted to kick him to the curb from the first chapter, and he never changed my mind. SO many things wrong there, including that a relationship should never EVER be based on pheromones alone. It was clear from the very beginning that he would never put Rita first, and she was straining to convince herself everything was fine & he was a good boyfriend. (See above about being grateful to have left my twenties behind.)

One other thing that really bothered me was that it seemed like Rajvee's gender fluidity was an afterthought or a late-in-the-editing process revision because someone said there needed to be an LGBTQIA character somewhere in the book. I was really excited at first when Vale introduced Raj's backstory because books are windows into someone else's experience, and I was looking forward to seeing how that character would develop. But aside from mentioning that Raj feels masculine sometimes and went shopping with Milan in high school for boys' clothes and (theoretically) uses all pronouns, the whole rest of the book depicts Raj as female. In fact, if Vale removed the section of the chapter where Rita recalls the history of Raj and Milan's friendship, I think you would never know Raj was anything but a cisgender woman. That was disappointing to me.

For readers' advisors: story doorway is primary. There is no violence, some swearing. Sex is depicted positively, mentioned regularly, and not described in detail. The main characters are all Indian-American, and most (all?) secondary characters are presumed white.

My thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free eBook ARC in exchange for my honest review!

View all my reviews

 

The Last Chance Library

The Last Chance Library by Freya Sampson
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

June Jones is 28 years old, lives alone, has no friends her own age, and hasn't gone anywhere or done anything since her mother lost her battle with cancer eight years ago. Painfully shy, June loves her job as a library assistant at the village library, where she is surrounded by the friendly whispers of the books on the shelves and the comfort of routines. The job itself is one she stumbled into ten years ago when her mother, one of the librarians on staff, became to ill to work, and the duo needed money to survive. But taking the job--and keeping it--meant foregoing her dream of college and becoming an author. Instead, June daydreams about the secret lives of the patrons and spends her free time reading the classics. Her mother's best friend, Linda, continues to prod June, hoping to convince her to wake up and live a little, but June is content to float through life wrapped in a cocoon of safe familiarity.

That cocoon evaporates the day the news comes out that the county council is considering closing six libraries, including Chalcot Library. June is devastated, and the regulars are up in arms. They form a protest group, FOCL (Friends of Chalcot Library, pronounced Fock All), to resist the closure, but as an employee, Jane is forbidden from participating in any way, including telling anyone why she isn't joining in. Tensions rise, and eventually June musters the courage to rebel by sending anonymous tips to FOCL regarding some underhanded backroom dealings she witnesses. She is encouraged to do this by her old school chum, Alex, the handsome attorney back in town to help with the family's Chinese food restaurant while his dad recovers from hip surgery.

Over time, June emerges from her self-imposed prison of grief and realizes how much she has missed. She also begins to realize just how much she doesn't know about the people she interacts with in the library every day, and how much more there is to their stories. Will it be too little, too late?

What I loved best about this book was that the author correctly identifies June as a library assistant and NOT a librarian. Becoming an actual librarian involves earning a bachelor's degree in any field AND a master's degree in library science. June hasn't been to college at all and therefore cannot be a librarian. Most people who work at libraries are assistants, and not librarians. Doesn't mean June isn't good at her job; it just means her training and experience is different.

I also loved getting to know the quirky characters, despite them each being well-known stereotypes: the homeless man, the brilliant child, the elderly curmudgeon, the outspoken voracious reader who hates all the books, the teenager seeking a quiet place to study, and the recent immigrant trying to make a go of it in her new home. I loved the way June's fantasies merged into Mrs. B's rants or queries from other patrons. I enjoyed watching June take steps into the world and cringed when she crumpled or was crushed by the Mean Girls. And I appreciated that the plot took a few zigs and zags to keep things a bit less predictable. Also June's impromptu scheme to kill two birds with one stone by redirecting Rocky away from the "hen do" and toward the FOCL rally cracked me up.

What I could have done without were the cliches--like her curly hair being pulled into a tight bun, her uber-lonely life with books as her only true friends, or the fact that despite working in a library for TEN YEARS, she seemed to have never read anything written in this century. I get that June's mom dressed her in random stuff from thrift shops, and she was a nerdy kid, but there is simply no way she was that isolated or clueless. Hurt by her best friend's betrayal, yes, but to the point of never ever making another friend? That just feels like the author is belittling the intelligence and social capabilities of readers, which sets my teeth on edge.

I haven't researched the state of British libraries, so I cannot speak to the likelihood of closures like this where over half the council seems oblivious to the obvious benefits to society of having a functional, funded library, or where greedy council members push a nefarious agenda, but it was reminiscent of both The Bookshop on the Corner by Jenny Colgan and The Library at the Edge of the World by Felicity Hayes-McCoy, so maybe it's a trend in the U.K. & Ireland?

Overall this book was a solid 3 stars out of 5 for me. I liked it, but it had serious flaws also. Many thanks to the publisher and to BookBrowse for the free ARC in exchange for my honest opinion!

For readers' advisors: character doorway is primary, setting (small village in England) is secondary. No sex or violence, but there is some occasional swearing, and grief related to cancer.

View all my reviews